10-Difference between fixed nozzle and Variable nozzle de-super heating

  

 De-superheating is the process of reducing the temperature of superheated steam. This is typically achieved by injecting a cooling medium, such as water, into the steam flow. The nozzles used in the desuperheating process can be classified as either variable nozzle or fixed nozzle de-superheaters. Here's

 The differences between these two types are:

Sl No.

Variable nozzle de-super heater

Fixed nozzle de-super heater

1

Variable nozzle desuperheating systems have adjustable nozzles that allow for controlling the flow rate of the cooling medium injected into the steam flow.

Fixed nozzle desuperheating systems have non-adjustable nozzles, meaning the cooling water flow rate and the degree of desuperheating are fixed

2

The nozzle opening can be adjusted to vary the amount of cooling water injected, thereby controlling the degree of desuperheating and achieving the desired steam temperature.

Separate control valve is required to adjust the water flow

3

More flexibility in adjusting the cooling water flow rate and achieving precise temperature control.

Not much accuracy in temperature control

4

Variable nozzle desuperheating systems are often used in applications that require tight temperature control,

USed where there is much tolerance in temperature control,

Ex: In process industries

They are commonly used in applications where a constant degree of desuperheating is sufficient, such as in industrial processes with steady steam loads or in small-scale power plants.

5

Complex design

Simple design

6

More costlier than fixed nozzle de-super heaters

Less costlier

7

Little bit complicated operation

Simple operation

8

Can be used for variable inlet flow & temperature

Used only for fixed flow & temperature

9

Size of nozzle is variable

Size of nozzle is fixed

10

Maintenance is difficult & costlier

Maintenance is simple & cheaper

 The choice between a variable nozzle and fixed nozzle desuperheater depends on factors such as the required temperature control accuracy, steam flow variability, plant operating conditions, and budget considerations. Variable nozzle desuperheaters are often preferred in applications where precise temperature control and flexibility are crucial, while fixed nozzle desuperheaters can be suitable for applications with relatively stable operating conditions and lower cost requirements.
































No comments:

Post a Comment

Hi all,
This article is written based on practical experience..If liked, share with others, or any suggestions leave in comment box.

15-Emergencies in power plant operation

Most visited posts